Repairing the Schaffner NSD200E Mains Interference Simulator.
And the dangers of bad mains filters capacitors, and RIFA brand in particular.
HVP-70 High voltage differential probe: https://www.eevblog.com/product/hvp70/
Forum: http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-1183-rifa-madness-(schaffner-repair)/'>http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-1183-rifa-madness-(schaffner-repair)/
Bitcoin Donations: 38y7DE8HEHNj8fGDtUr4PkCn9nWxiorvvy
Litecoin: ML7oQokTwB38bgzzjLDbRV97HKAHuwRfHA
Ethereum: 0x11AceA38DCA9DbFfB4F35f3F746af65F9dED28ce
EEVblog Main Web Site: http://www.eevblog.com
The 2nd EEVblog Channel: http://www.youtube.com/EEVblog2
Support the EEVblog through Patreon!
http://www.patreon.com/eevblog
AliExpress Affiliate: http://s.click.aliexpress.com/e/c2LRpe8g
Buy anything through that link and Dave gets a commission at no cost to you.
Stuff I recommend:
https://kit.com/EEVblog/
Donate With Bitcoin & Other Crypto Currencies!
https://www.eevblog.com/crypto-currency/
T-Shirts: http://teespring.com/stores/eevblog
Likecoin โ Coins for Likes: https://likecoin.pro/ @eevblog/dil9/hcq3
And the dangers of bad mains filters capacitors, and RIFA brand in particular.
HVP-70 High voltage differential probe: https://www.eevblog.com/product/hvp70/
Forum: http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-1183-rifa-madness-(schaffner-repair)/'>http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-1183-rifa-madness-(schaffner-repair)/
Bitcoin Donations: 38y7DE8HEHNj8fGDtUr4PkCn9nWxiorvvy
Litecoin: ML7oQokTwB38bgzzjLDbRV97HKAHuwRfHA
Ethereum: 0x11AceA38DCA9DbFfB4F35f3F746af65F9dED28ce
EEVblog Main Web Site: http://www.eevblog.com
The 2nd EEVblog Channel: http://www.youtube.com/EEVblog2
Support the EEVblog through Patreon!
http://www.patreon.com/eevblog
AliExpress Affiliate: http://s.click.aliexpress.com/e/c2LRpe8g
Buy anything through that link and Dave gets a commission at no cost to you.
Stuff I recommend:
https://kit.com/EEVblog/
Donate With Bitcoin & Other Crypto Currencies!
https://www.eevblog.com/crypto-currency/
T-Shirts: http://teespring.com/stores/eevblog
Likecoin โ Coins for Likes: https://likecoin.pro/ @eevblog/dil9/hcq3
Hi. In the previous video we took a look at the teardown of this Schaffner NSG 200 and NSG triple 2i interference mains. interference simulators are very cool and interesting bit of kit so I'll link it in down below if you haven't seen it. Anyway, we thought that there was a failure in the transformer over here, but well let's take a closer look now.
Of course when I plug this thing in it took some time but eventually while I was trying to use it, release the magic smoke and I thought it was coming around this back area here because the the top part of it just has all grills on it like this so the smoke was sort of coming out of this back region so we're not opened it up and I saw this down here I thought AHA that looks like the culprit this huge common mode choke on here and you can see it does actually look as if like something like has burnt and then melted and dripped down and something like that. But as I remarked in that video because this is just a common mode choke I I found it really hard to think of the mechanism that would actually cause it to do that because it's not like you know a transformer anything if one turn just shorts to another so you know it's not really a big deal. And anyway so I didn't really investigate it any further. so it seemed like that was the culprit.
but as it turns out one of my viewers actually worked or is still working at a transformer manufacturing company. he said no, this is actually quite common. It just looks like the residue from the Polly put the Kettle On coding that they actually apply to this thing and it's no big deal like that is not a burn mark at all. And upon closer inspection I am pretty darn sure he's right because look, it looks like it's sort of like dripped out of there like that.
So yeah, I don't reckon I think now. I'm pretty confident also that this is not the burn mark, so let's go have a look elsewhere. Now as many people in the comments spotted, these are for Capacitors reefers. A brand of these safety capacitors are filter capacitors that go down to mains Earth X class and Y class caps and these are actually notorious for failing after a long time because what happens is the plastic casing on these things actually are cracks and moisture gets into them.
and then if you've got these things like sitting around in storage for 10 or 20 years and then you try and pair them on bang, the magic smoke escapes and pretty pungent odor comes out of these things, but usually they're quite. You know, all the ones I've seen are usually quite violent. and here's some. Our photos just pulled off our Google images of various our reefer brand.
It can happen to other ones, but these reefer ones. A comment that use these are plastic enclosures. They're practically infamous for doing this after you know their 20-30 years something like that and I originally looked at these I went on. No, they look okay at first glance when we had what looked like a burn mark on the transformer where I thought the smoke was coming out of. but upon closer inspection, these do look a bit dodgy. so I didn't really give those more than a casual glance before. But if we look closer upon second inspection I think we can see something down in here? It's hard. I'll try get the lens down because it's hard to get this board out.
By the way it it's like yeah, it's not easy if you have a look down in there now it seems pretty obvious I didn't notice this but you'll notice that big crack in there like that I didn't see that before and if you can see it, big crack down there as well and I can yeah I can feel that there we are there we go get the screwdriver in there. So yeah, I pays to look a little bit closer and not get caught up in thinking that you've found the culprit. especially when I couldn't really explain why that common mode choke would have like caught on fire and smoke - really, there was just no mechanism for it. So yep, that now seems pretty obvious.
So what I'm gonna do is get all those caps out of there. And the good thing about these is that they're not actually necessary for the operation of the unit. so I can simply remove them and power the thing back up and at least get it working. I mean I You know I should actually replace them and I will of course.
and you should. By the way, if you find any old gear, vintage computers, or any other vintage Teske or anything else that uses these reefer brand caps or similar looking ones for mains, input filter in Eva directly across the mains or down from active and neutral down to earth, then replace them. It's a real good idea because they might eventually go bang ski. Oh by the way, if you get in in there and desoldering like old gear like this, there can be like lots of real crusty old flux residue on there and it really goes up in smoke and it's just it's nasty stuff.
I Have actually have been at a job where we actually set off somebody in the lab at like repairing old gear and they bought some old gear in at once and started working on it. Nope. Fire alarm went off, built in, evacuated and yeah, lots of red faces all around. Oops yeah, look at that.
Lots of it. Whoo! I Think what they've actually done with this thing is the board actually gets assembled onto the transformer. The transformer dropped in, all the wires are plugged in and then they screw it down like this: I've unscrewed the transformer. It kind of sort of comes out, but there's lots of wires, just like some of them are permanently connected and stuff like that, so forget the bottom plate on I Can kinda sorta get in there and maybe get the D solder the board off.
but jeez, it's it's really quite annoying. Well yep, that's obvious, isn't it? Look at that. and if that was just sitting on the board like that would have been just so obvious that this thing was blowing. But because it was like you know, tucked away in there and it was harder to see, you can see, it's like bows out and expanded. All of the cases just completely cracked everywhere. like that big - big splits on the bottom. and yep, magic smokers escaped and all the other ones look real dodgy brothers to look and see the cracks in there look at all. Wow, that's just yep.
look straight across. but that's you know, most of these other ones we're impossible to see inside there. Once again, you might go out and probably see maybe the Bulge and the cracks. These things are just absolutely hopeless as practically a hundred percent follow your rate.
In fact, there is a hundred percent fo your rate on these Wow and lucky last there you go. Yep, all completely dodgy and these smaller ones are the Y class caps and the Y class caps are go from active and or mutual down-to-earth whereas this one is an X o'clock Yeah, X class and half an X class and darkest half. the magic smokers escaped and the X class goes directly across the 240 volt or 110 volt mains. So there you go.
Yep, classic reefer capacitor failure. Yep, it would have been bleeding Lee obviously if they weren't sort of like hidden away in there and we didn't have the other red herring that we chased with the transformer. So there you go, Easy peasy. So according to the schematic, this one was a 5 micro farad job and the only X2 I have to hand our brand new is this naught point one mic one and look, it doesn't really matter.
5 micro farad's actually is for the 50 60 Hertz model. it's actually lower value for the 400 Hertz capable thing and we're only talking about a you know, basically a filter in here. So as I said, this thing will at work without any of these caps are installed. There just are suppression filtering caps basically.
so I don't know I could try this. or maybe I could like steal some from an old board perhaps something like this. Here's a bunch of well there they be. Yep, there.
x2 class cap so 470 and there you go. So slightly larger so maybe I can steal some for them and these look like Y class caps in here. You can tell because they're actually going to ground here. You can see that they're across there like that so they're actually going in there to ground.
But the part number. fortunately it's a bit odd ball and these ones are actually a X1 and Y1 class cap. so they're quite nice. Unfortunately, very low in value 101.
there would be 100 or a hundred puffs, but hey, check out that one that's a 820 nanofarad Y class cap. noise. And of course once again because it's Y class, you see it going over to ground here. So as you can see, it's handy to have like a scrap board like this in your jumping because you can.
You know these are still a great quality cap. so you can, you know suck these out and use them. If you've got like an old bit of gear that's you know, all the magic smoke all the snots escaped from his old reefer type or other brand. you know X or Y class caps then yeah, you know these are perfectly good to use. So as I said, these are X class capacitors. in this case X2 which is the second highest rating 1 X1 is actually the highest and you can get lower than that, but X2 is by far the most common and Y2 ones which were there. this one just says y so I'm You know it's a really old one so I'm not sure what the deal is there, but anyway, but they are designed for different purposes. As I said, the X class goes across the mains and they're designed so that they don't fail short ie.
they don't catch on fire because it's directly across the mains. It's got low impedance, lots of energy behind it, so they're designed not to explode. Um, that. That was the plan.
Anyway, yeah, these older ones do unfortunately degrade over time, but they're supposed to not do that, whereas your Y class caps are designed to go from active or neutral down to ground. And they're designed not to have any leakage at all down to ground. so they're designed for different purposes. Now, you can actually use a Y class cap in the X configuration, but you can't use an X class cap.
We shouldn't use an x-class cap in a Y class configuration. It's just a safety thing. You can see some ooze down there on the board that's just spewed out at the bottom of that cap. We'll just clean that off before we put a replacement in.
One of the problems with Sol during a board in situ like this: when it's vertical like that is the soda. actually. with large like ground planes with no soda mask, the soda actually falls down under its own weight under gravity. So you really have to flip this board up horizontal in order to sold it properly.
I've just got a regular like a tinned copper. PCB like this one, right? So I'm actually fairly confident to turn this back on now, because I'm pretty darn sure that there's nothing wrong with that transformer. We've taken out all the X&Y class caps. I mean we we had 5, 4, 5 failures there.
That's just insane. I don't have any y class eye caps in there which are power these two neons as well as are doing some filtering down to earth. Now a few people in the comments and quite a few actually mention that possibly this thing could have died because I was like a pulse in this thing without a load. and there's absolutely no way that I can imagine where that would cause a problem because this bigger sphere.
that's what this big ass filter and this big ass choke do here. And that's the whole point of having these enormous things so that all the output pulse all the output pulses on here don't affect the input. and not having a load on there shouldn't be an issue whatsoever. So um, let's just pair it on and see what we get.
Yep, we're back up and running sweet as you go. and I've got a course that seated that chip back in there. So that's maybe why I couldn't like before it and the magic smoke escaped I couldn't actually I get any pulses on the scope. so I'll hook up the scope again. Give it a ball. Okay, switch the output on. Bingo. there's a sine wave.
Beautiful. Let's see if we get a pulse on it. And of course, as I've mentioned, when you're doing tests like this high voltage stuff, you need a proper high voltage probe available in the Eevblog store. Plug my merge.
A lot of people don't know that I sell this. It's a very nice high voltage probe divided by a hundred beautiful and it plugs straight in with the banana jacks. Okay, so I'm going to set it to a hundred nano second pulse here. just symmetric or whatever.
I'm gonna set it to our five hundred volt pulse and we're gonna single pulse this thing. And we set the scope up for a hundred to one probe because that's what our high voltage probe is and we're at 200 volts per division there. So let's run that. You can see that's actually live.
So what we want to do is set our trigger point just above that. There you go. so it's now free running. We'll put it on normal mode.
then we'll single-shot capture that. Now if we trigger it, hopefully we'll capture something. It's the plan. Wow Yep, got one something in there.
That's how. It doesn't look like there's anything in there, but aha, because it's only a hundred nano second pulse and we're currently at five milliseconds per division. Bingo, There it is. Leave that and that's at 20 nanoseconds per division.
forty. So you know it's roughly a hundred down a second pulse. Something like that. Let's actually set it for ten nanoseconds and see if it's faster.
So I'll keep the time base like that and single-shot capture that again. Ten nanoseconds and single. Bingo. Ma, it's the same.
Bueller Bueller. Let's try again. It's the same again. ten or hundred nanoseconds doesn't seem to make much of a difference.
Oh Anyway, it's working and if we change the polarity on there sorry about the glare of the screen. um yeah. I do have like an anti glare filter I just haven't put it on yet. It's a great scope, but yeah, the screen glare is terrible.
Um, I've changed polarity and let's zoom in and bingo is our pulse nice and I'll double the amplitude I'll single shot it again and oh, there we go. It's a bit problematic. Um, it's it's just picking a random location on the waveform cuz I'm just free pressing it here. So I've actually set it to one kilovolt pulse this time and let's sync.
Here we go. That's L1 kilovolt pulse. It's not huge, is it? So we're actually working A treat there. This is a winner winner chicken dinner.
So there you have it. As predicted in the previous video, this thing actually works I Didn't think that'd be anything hugely wrong with it I Just think it was just so plus two requirements or whatever. Maybe you know it doesn't support the new testing standard their testing 2 or whatever. but and it's probably been sitting around for a long time. which is why these damn reefer caps have failed. And these are, you know, like, notorious for failing like this. It's just like over long term, the modern ones are a lot better, but these are older ones. just absolutely horrible.
they're They're infamous for doing that. so if you've got any old gear or anything with these, just replace them as a matter of course. even if they haven't failed. especially if the thing has been like I believe it's different if you keep them like you know, powered up 24/7 for like you know, 15, 20 years or whatever I believe they're They actually do have a longer life, but yeah, if you put them in storage and then just try and pair them up and they've got moisture in there or whatever, it's like poof.
Well, the magic smokes going to escape in this case. we were five, four, five. I mean all of those have failed. They've all got crap in the case or what.
Not that they just look horrible. Look at them. it's awful and that's how bad these things are. Five four, five.
Unbelievable. But it looks like we've got it working. I'll eventually get some my class caps to put it back in there and you know, restore it to its original thing. but it looks like I have roughly working.
You know you could try out all the functionality and everything, but that could take some time but it seems to be generating the pulses that we want so that's a very nice mains interference simulator for the lab. Awesome! Test our products now just pulse it in there see if they fail. Terrific stuff. Anyway, if you liked the video, please give it a big thumbs up because that always helps a lot and you can discuss it down below in the comments or over on the EEV look for catch you next time.
My Zanussi washer dryer had one of these but instead of cracking right away the plastic expanded with the capacitor inside it until it finally cracked and started turning off my rcd all of the time
Bloody RIFAs. I've witnessed several of these go off, but none as dramatic as inside a Grundig VCR from the 90s. It dented the can containing the PSU and even lifted and catapulted the fuse right out of its socket! The fuse was surprisingly still ok, but the whole PSU compartment was littered with shrapnel.
By now I've learned to preemptively replace them; it takes minutes compared to the hours you'll spend cleaning up the mess, particularly the sticky flameproof resin!
Could you explain the importance of X capacitors? I have plug in surge protectors that self-consume 29-43 mA, and I suspect it is the X capacitors leaking current! Was wondering what effect if I remove them?
I'm guessing that this is what happened to my old Hameg oscilloscope. I powered it on and it was fine for about 5 minutes, and then a loud BANG and a ton of smoke, but the scope still stayed on. Gave me a heart attack lol.
I see these, I immediately take them out and replace them without even checking if they are good or not. I had so many of them explode in the past.
In the past couple of years Yamaha have done a product recall on 30 year old amplifiers which were fitted with RIFA smoke bombs. On the same audio forum someone had posted pictures of a RIFA capacitor that had exploded despite having never been fitted into a board. No smoke but the thing had completely split apart.
Stories from me about RIFA capacitors.
1). Hope your vacuum cleaner doesn't have one fitted. With all the air going through you won't see smoke but you will smell it everywhere.
2). If equipment fails check for these. My Mother threw away all the accessories for her expensive sewing machine and asked me to take the machine to the tip thinking the motor had burnt out. Out of curiosity I looked inside and it was a RIFA capacitor next to the motor had released all its smoke.
3). I'm watching this after having a second Philips Oscilloscope release all the magic smoke from one of these.
Thank you.
I find these all the time in old Numatic vacuum cleaners.
I just had the mains input filter go bang on a Tektronix TSG131A video signal generator. Big cloud of acrid smoke too. Made in the mid 90's. The input filter is in a metal can forming part of the IEC input socket, with the filter caps potted internally. Some people have opened them up and found RIFA style caps. The smoke and resulting smell was terrible, took days to clear!
Just had one blow up on a Revox B 760, thats how I got here! Smelled like nasty old cigarettes.
Yes Dave they are supposed to crack and vent. The idea is to take out surges and power spikes, they generally can only ever handle a few surges before they start to vent. The plastic blue potted ones tend to go with a enormous bang as they are sealed however the Rifa type crack and vent without exploding violently. They are a sacrificial capacitor, they take the hit and protect the rest of the circuit.
When I solder in hotel rooms i find the shower cap provides a nice cover for the smoke detector ๐
Merci beaucoup pour cette vidรฉo. Je vais changer tous les Rifa de mon TEKTRONIX des annรฉes 80. Merci encore et Bonjour de France.
I had a beautiful, new old stock HP 5328B that went pop and a small amount of magic smoke came out. Looked inside for an exploded electrolytic, found none, and set it aside after some head-scratching. I just wonder if it's suffering from RIFA madness….?
Apple II owners are VERY familiar with these. Love the title!
Few months ago I put a comment because I repaired a ye olde Swiss made Meteor winder from mid 70's. Electromechanical motor controller was virtually blown out by those Rifa caps. Now I had another popcornish Rifa caps madness. The victim was an auxiliary SMPS assembled in Mexico inside a mid 90's QUAD IVc MK2 pick and place machine "proudly made in the USA" (cuac!). In this ocassion those common mode filter components don't caused massive destruction, but in our cold humid Buenos Aires winter conditions, became leaky and the nearby Laser aligment controller gone crazy.
So, the moral is: If you see an old Rifa cap, just change it!
By the way. Dave, I liked so much your differntial probe! If my coutry's economy goes better (and my own), I may consider to get a pair of those. My lab colleagues have a devotion for frying oscilloscope probes as if they were gifted them!! :-(((
Used as filters in singer sewing machine pedals made in clydebank Scotland. Got my mums down from loft after 20 years and erupted in smoke. Replaced and its fine now.
Well, one of these RIFA's just smoked it up in my recently acquired HP 6236B bench Power Supply. Smelled like burning paper, nothing too pungent. Sheet mun
Those damn RIFA capacitors again !
Itโs a shame you didnโt end the video by demonstrating the effectiveness of a healthy X class cap across the output of the device under test. That would have been cool!
This is why old Kenwood Chefs blow up as well, cheap fix though.
Last Week i had the same Magic Rifa Smoke in a Tapedeck… a
The one type of RIFA you don't wanna smoke
I find one of your advertisers to be offensive and annoying . The one hawking "patriot T shirts".
Audiophiles would buy that RIFA "vintage" for a hundred dollars, just named it, vintage RIFA, RARE ITEM!
I always choose wima caps, they're HiQ and i like the red color.
Beware the RIFA phenomenon! I bought a Tektronix digital storage scope (CRT) in perfect working condition. Plugged it in, turned it on – started up fine. Ten minutes later … BANG! Ffffsssssssssssssssssssssssssssss….. Poo! The cooling fan sucked all the magic smoke and stink and blew it out in my direction. Open it up – TA DA! Mr Rifa strikes again.
reefer caps and Bourns makes pot in Mexico, how wonderful
Dave, doesn't that first switch just change the rise time between 5ns and 10ns?
You seemed to be expecting it to change the pulses between 100ns and 10ns, but I'm sure you mentioned rise time in the previous video and the "Tr" notation seems to allude to that.
Good score by the way. I've been looking to get one of these for a while, but very few show up in Australia, and shipping from overseas is often far too expensive.