Follow Dave as he tracks down an elusive intermittent thermal fault in a HP1740A analog oscilloscope.
Can you figure out the culprit before Dave does?
Part 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cmz8bzUsj7E
Forum: http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-804-hp1740a-oscilloscope-repair-part-2/'>http://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-804-hp1740a-oscilloscope-repair-part-2/
https://teespring.com/warrantyvoid2
Original HP Journal article on the HP1740A:
http://www.hpl.hp.com/hpjournal/pdfs/IssuePDFs/1975-12.pdf
How not to blow up your oscilloscope:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xaELqAo4kkQ
EEVblog Main Web Site: http://www.eevblog.com
The 2nd EEVblog Channel: http://www.youtube.com/EEVblog2
Support the EEVblog through Patreon!
http://www.patreon.com/eevblog
EEVblog Amazon Store (Dave gets a cut):
http://astore.amazon.com/eevblogstore-20
T-Shirts: http://teespring.com/stores/eevblog
Donations:
http://www.eevblog.com/donations/
Projects:
http://www.eevblog.com/projects/
Electronics Info Wiki:
http://www.eevblog.com/wiki/
๐Ÿ’— Likecoin โ€“ Coins for Likes: https://likecoin.pro/ @eevblog/dil9/hcq3

Hi Just a follow-up video to this: HB 1740 800 megahertz dual channel analog oscilloscope and the repair of this thing and where we got to last time was that we found that once we took the case off this thing, it basically would not fail except for one very small CAPTCHA that I got by coincidence as I was tweeting a photo where all of the power rails 5 different power rails on the output of this secondary linear transformer. This is in a switch mode converter supply, so five different linear rails all dropped at once and well I left the thing for like at least four hours. It might have been closer to 5 hours or something like that. Still would not fail.

So it's either a thermal problem where the unit where because the the case is now off this thing, the heat can escape, it can't build up inside and the thing is not is upside down now. So if it is something to do with the power supply for example or are something on the bottom like this board here, then you know the heat doesn't sort of build up inside that case. But it may not be a thermal problem, it may actually be a mechanical issue. So let me actually explain on the schematic here what I'm talking about.

but before we do that, if you're trying to capture intermittent faults which I wasn't here by the way because I you know I thought I'd just sit there for an hour and then just fail I wanted to see what the rails did but I didn't know it would have that like intermittent. You know, a dropout like I I captured by accident. So if you want to do that with your meters, you'll hook them up and you use your min Max mode. So that's what I've done on these 4 meters here and I've left the thing once again for another like hour or so and I haven't been able to capture everything anything at all before.

This thing was easily failing within the hour and it was fairly repeatable at that. but I haven't put the case back on everything anyway. I've set them to min max mode so it'll capture any transients which go low. So I've got it display in the minimum at the moment, but it's always it's in min.

Max record mode. All of these meters. even this old flute 27 has it and I'm actually displaying the minimum. so maybe I can.

Actually, how do I simulate a mains Brown out or something just by wiggling the power cord or something like that? Perhaps Here we go. I'll give it a go and they'll all jump down. Just a trap for young players. If you've got a negative rail like this, you don't want to set it to minimum.

like I've said. this one. if you're looking to get Brown outs and drops in the voltage, you've got to set this one to maximum because it's a negative voltage. so it'll go up towards zero effectively.

so you know. So it's actually maximum so I don't know? Let me see if I can wiggle this mains lead on the input I could switch it off an arm, but that's it. you know I want to get like a way there. We go there, we go.

I did something there we go. Drop down. there we go. So that was just by wiggling the mains lead on the input so we're able to work.
Capture that now. As I said in the previous video, looking at the schematic for the main power supply board, you can see it's it's basically a standard linear transformer. It's got multiple isolated taps, two four, six different tap see all going to standard bridge rectifier, a full wave bridge rectifiers, and then the big filter caps the big old ones from us. Prague and Mallory I think they are anyway.

but yeah, we've got a linear regulator chip you know, pass transistor mounted on the back. all kind of. You know it's standard stuff. but basically I'm measuring the output of most of these are measuring five.

I think we've got six taps here anyway. I'm measuring five main rails here and they all dropped according to that photo even though I have not been able to reproduce it yet. but we did actually capture that drop. So you've got to assume what can drag all five rails after the linear regulators down.

As I said, they have each one's got individual current-limiting hidden here, a current limit, output resistor, and it's got current limiting inside the chip. Whatever chip that is. I'm not sure, but it doesn't matter. Um, how would you drag all the output of all those linear regulators low? Well, the most obvious think like because if you just shorted out one here, for example, even if they say this diode bridge rectifier shorted out, it did something weird something.

you know you load that down, didn't have any protection, etc. I Don't know the cap was doing something weird. You know it's unlikely to drag down any of the others because of the low impedance source through the transformer. It's just not going to affect it these other channels so odds on it's got to be something on the primary side which is causing a drop out because then anything that happens on the primary side.

if it can't deliver enough power, then the outputs here because these are all drawing. I don't know how much power this scope draws, You know? I don't know, 10 20 watts or something, right? You know it's a reasonable amount of power. Okay, so if this primary side for some reason cannot deliver that power, all of these outputs are likely to drop while the outputs of the outputs of the linear regulator here. but you know, obviously the outputs of the transform will drop and then bingo it'll go through to the linear outputs.

So the first thing I would suspect is something on the primary side of this transformer and just forget what's going on down here with these couple of transistors. This is just some interface stuff for the two B and C's the gating outputs. the main and delay gating outputs on the rear panel There just happen to use those as a convenient jumping from one board to the other because the board happened to be there so they're mounted on there and doesn't matter. So that's got nothing to do with this main site and the main site is incredibly simple.
We've got a an I AC mains input connector here, one amp fuse on the input, and then we've got our switch. Okay, that's our front panel line switch on the front panel. and then we've got a the voltage selection switches which is on the base of the unit down in here. and and then then you've got some socket wire in contacts.

you've got your PCB connector going off to here. So I am suspecting possibly first point of call would ever be the front panel main switch or the main selection switch here. because these are. you've got to remember, these are like what? 30 This is 1980.

Okay, so this is a 35 year old scope. so these are 35 year old switches. 35 year old contacts on there and contacts can pit and corrode over time with use for example. So if the contacts are pitted and they can, and because they got power reasonably, you know, not super high power flowing through it, right? We're only talking 10 or 20 watts or whatever this scope takes, but it's enough current to cause a potential issue.

So if the contacts either in here or maybe the front panel main switch are pitted then it could potentially have no change. Well like under our time. Maybe it heats up a little bit. Maybe it's got a little bit of high resistance and then slowly heats up inside until some you know something happens on the surface contact of the switches in here, which then it causes not to be able to deliver enough power to the transformer.

so all the outputs are gonna drop. That's the first thing I Want to check? So yeah, you could go right down the rabbit hole trying to look at all the other boards in the thing and what? Evers Hooked on to the output of all of these channels here. see if one of them's load and down and you can chase that rabbit hole. But I think that's pretty foolish because they all seem to drop so this I think.

Definitely worth looking at. So I think if you didn't have a look around here first, you were, you know, gone for a wander down the garden path. Now the problem with this is is I cannot reproduce the fault. So what on I'll probably have to do first.

maybe off cameras to disconnect all the multimeters, put the covers back on, run the thing for an hour and see if I can actually reproduce the problem. But anyway, there is our mains input voltage selection so there's some like PCB contact switches under there. It looks like we might be able to take that off an inspector, but they're probably like, you know PCB solder connectors on there and yeah, I can go and you know it's probably almost impossible to expect inspect because they're probably sealed switches in there. We'll have a look in a second.

but yeah, I could go and spray some. you know, contact cleaner in them in in those. But the problem is if I can't reproduce the fault, how do I know that I've fixed it? So yeah, we have to try and reproduce the fault first before we go spray the contacts. It's uh, it's great to have this theory that it's probably something to do with the contacts somewhere.
It's not likely to be the board to board, but you might take those out. have a look at the contacts on there just as matter. of course though, we got one. I got lucky I just switched I just disconnected the mains power cord out the back and then reconnected at am.

Bingo! look I on the screen down here. Now it's ad why bother setting up another camera shot but have a look. It's like yeah, like there is nothing I can't adjust that we get in. you know, just that fixed line and all of the rails.

All the rails are low. Look at that. Why? Hmm. Okay, so these aren't in min/max anymore.

Okay, so I'm gonna wiggle that mains cord and see what the problem is. Nope. So I'm wiggling the mains input connector. Okay, so it's not that.

Let me show you that. I'll show you my wiggling. Let's wiggle the front panel line switch. Give that a little bit of a can see that I'm given that a bit of a bit of a jiggle.

There we go. Nothing doing down in there I'll get my isolated Trotter Well, these are all secondary so no drama there. Give those a bit of a bit of a wiggle. These are the main mains connectors give those a wiggle and main switches those faulty selection switches.

although I'm only hitting the top. Maybe I can hit the board? No, nothing. It's permanently low. So here we go: I will my power? let me repay with the back.

here. there's all the rails droppin. Hey, look, has it permanently failed now? Excellent. Oh, that's what we want.

That's what we want. Permanent failure, you bloody Rippa. Now we're getting somewhere Murphy's on his lunch break I Think All right. So let's test our primary side.

Theory Here, the way we can do that is take for example, just one of the rails. We're doing one at a time. Otherwise, I don't need like ten multimeters. Let's take the five volt output here.

Okay, so the five volt output goes through this pass transistor and it goes into this side two plus nine point five volts there to this fifth s C11, this 53 hundred microfarad cap on the output of this full wave bridge rectifier. So if this doesn't measure nine volts, orth actually says nine volts here, and then nine Point Five volts there. A little discrepancy. Anyway, if it doesn't measure around about nine volts or you know, significantly higher then the five volts because the dropout voltage of the pass transistor here.

So let's assume in say it's a two volt maximum dropout voltage. it's gonna need at least seven volts to regulate this thing. So if it's not, at least you know it really should be around about that nine volt figure. If it's not, then we know.

Bingo! The primary side is not being able to supply enough power on that particular winding and most likely on all the other windings as well. So here we go: I've got another meter here set up across that fifty three hundred microfarad I cap down in there. It's still got some charge on it, hasn't been able to bleed it off because they haven't got a bleeder resistor on there. So the all that you know the regulator I see is the pass transistors switched off and there's still some charge there anyway.
so let's pair it on. Hopefully it still fails. so let's pair it still. Oh oh, it's working.

Nine volts, you bastard. Oh no, no. Hang on. No seven volts.

You saw it here. We go there, we go. It's droppin. So there's our five volt rail.

There's a five volt rail. 4.2 volts. No wonder you know it's it. Well actually, point Two Volts regulation I'm pretty good actually.

So, uh yeah. but look, so it's dropped and all the others rails have dropped as well. But you can see that the output of the full wave bridge rectifier at its failed of course. and so the output of the full wave bridge rectifier is it cannot.

you know, is is dropped. So that means our price is most likely our primary side of the transformer cannot supply enough power. Let me check one of the other rails. Okay, I've now hooked it up to our six thousand micro farad cab.

That's through our plus fifteen volt regulated output. the output of the bridge rectifier on that cap. As we should read on here, it should be about 21 volts or thereabout. So it's paradigm.

Yep, it's failed again. Highs as repeatable. Hey, no, we're still kidding. Look at that.

That's interesting. Wow There you go and lost that bit. That's enough. That is more than enough to give out regulated fifteen volts output.

But we're not getting our regulated fifteen volts output, so that's really interesting. Hmm. and there we go. That's interesting.

This is the negative RA Oh, it shows positive the hair I've hooked it up back to front Murphy Got me? Anyway, that's the negative rail. so we're looking at negative 22 volts so that's correct as well. Oh wow. I really lost that bet and so, but our negative rail is minus 12, but it's got more than enough voltage to regulate it.

It's got the regular output voltage expected from that full wave bridge rectifier. and let's try the 42 volt rail as well. I've got it across. The 500 Mike 75 volt cap should be about 55 volts according to the rail.

And yet, but we're all good again. Bloody Hell. Come on. Fail Fail.

Come on. you can do it. You can fail. Come on.

And there we go. It's failed, but it's at 60 volts so it's actually jumped up. which seems to and you know, like there's less load on there. So yeah, that's interesting.

but we lose regulation. so maybe there's something that's tie. maybe an overload on the five volt rail or perhaps into. well, that causes dropout of regulation of the other channels.
Hmm. but the bridge rectifier outputs the all the other ones are fine. It's only the five volt rail I can actually whack that one back. What was it? This big one here? There we go.

No hang on. No twas this one here, was it? Can never remember? Yeah, there we go. Four volts. No good whatsoever.

and I'm just having to look at the ripple on the five volt rail here and we're on two volts per division and as you can see, it's just over that tight. Yeah that four volts that we can see over there. I Haven't got the multimeter on the rail, but yeah it's you. know that 4.2 volts or whatever we were seeing before and the ripple is basically bugger.

Oh look at that, the main output voltage is dropped. and by the way, if you're gonna our scope, probe these things. I've done a whole video on light mains, ground, earth referencing and you're probably better off for using an isolation night transformer when you're testing something like this. Or just make sure your ground reference point for your probe is actually shezzy ground.

otherwise you can blow the arse out of you scope and all your product. Okay, I'm trying to make it come good now, but it's no, it's not going to come good but you know it's not like the capacitor has failed and then otherwise would see huge amount of ripple on here cuz it should be what normally aren't nine volts or whatever. so you know two, four, six eight. You know it should be like up here and you know if the cap was troublesome we'd see you know a large amount of ripple but I was seeing hardly any ripple on there at all.

So it's it. must be drawing excess current and it's it's just dragging that down the output winding. It can't provide enough power. So what we need to do now is go back to our schematic and have a closer look at what's happening here, because what we've been doing up until now, we didn't like sit down there and analyzed all how the power supply work.

Made a few assumptions and it was actually quite reasonable to suspect the primary side because all of our outputs dropped and so we did the right thing we said, We came up with a quite plausible theory about the primary side. here. We went about testing it by and we actually found that our five Volt the output of our bridge rectifier. here.

on our five volt rail, there's nine volts actually dropped right down. Okay, so that seemed to confirm that theory. But then when I went to double check, always double check this. Okay, don't assume anything.

So I went and measured the other rails here and these other rails weren't being dragged down. So that fact basically ruled out our primary side. Theory high impedance primary side dragging everything down on these secondaries. So we have to go check the rest of the circuit and see what's what.
Okay, so what we've got here is our three. Let let's just look at this like ignore all these complicated looking ones with the transistors up top. Let's just like concentrate on what's happening to the five volt. And the plus minus fifteen volt rails here.

now. so we've got three regulator ICS here. Okay, and but when you actually look closer at these, Okay, this one here is the one for the +5 volt rail. Sorry, Plus 15 volt rail.

Okay, so we've got our plus 22 volts coming in here and we measured that that it was still 22 volts, yet our output was actually being dragged down. Now, this looks a fairly typical look. Here's our output here. Our Plus 15.

Well, there we go. Sorry, you can't see that, but here there it is a plus 15 volt output here. and we've got our L Look, we've got a voltage adjustment pot here for the fifteen volt. so we've got their typical output voltage divider feeding back and actually into our regulator here using this external pass transistor and that is a very, very typical you know voltage regulator.

But we know we're measuring 22 volts here. but we're not getting 15 volts out of here. Why? But more interestingly, let's take a look at another one down here. Okay, is the negative 15 volt one? Where is? Where are the feedback resistors from this minor from this negative output rail? Look, Aha, here's our feedback resistors.

Look, it's reference to the fifteen volt rail the plus fifteen volt rail here. So this is not independent. It actually relies on the fact that this fifteen volt rail is set correctly. And then if you go, look at the five Volt voltage regulator.

Uh-huh right? Here's our output. Here is our Apple current sense resistor. Here's our Series Pass transistor. Where is the voltage reference coming from? Bingo! The plus Fifteen volt rail.

Again, So that plus fifteen volt rail drags down. Of course, it'll drag down the five volt rail. Of course it'll drag down the negative fifteen volt rail. So it looks like the all the rails there are referenced to that plus 15 volts output.

And of course, wouldn't you know it? If you actually go and read the theory of operation of this thing, it tells you exactly that. Look at this: All Voltages Plus Five, Forty Three Hundred and Twenty Plus Minus fifteen, what would be measuring and the high voltage our reference to the plus fifteen volt supply. Dole. So everything cause it so it must be made operational.

First, the supplies a current limiting type of who As we've seen, they've got those current limit resistors. so any excessive loading on the vertical, horizontal, etc will cause the supply to read twenty to thirty percent low. And that's what we've been seen. So of course they're going to.

it's going to drag down all of the rails. Okay, so what it actually told you to do in the troubleshooting procedure and what's obvious is to actually remove this board here. which connects the output of the power supply here to all the other boards here, the horizontal and the vertical boards. and, well, that's a really that's really is very nice.
it just that slips out like that because we've got card edge connectors on here. They are looking great condition. There's no no corrosion at all on there. everything's beautifully gold-plated and be very thick gold plating to top-notch No worries whatsoever.

And looking at the rails and of course they're all bang on. I Might just leave it for a while and see if it fails, but I suspect neither. There's something that's dragging down one of those rails. And of course, with no horizontal and no vertical, what do we get? We get a dot straight in the middle because it ain't driving it left-right, up-down or wherever and you can actually see the high voltage output here still connected to the board down here.

So we still drive all there high voltage stuff. We're still driving our CRT and everything else. It's just that we're not connected through to our horizontal and our vertical boards here. So what we're doing now is just checking to see if it's the horizontal or the vertical boards at fault here, see if our problem returns.

But as we've as we've been seeing here, these intermittent faults are a pain in the ass because you don't know whether or not you're just getting lucky and the faults not showing up. It could be in the high voltage section which is still being powered from here. as I said, it could still be in there. but you know there could be some reason why it's not showing.

You know? Murphy You'll get you every time, so you know just because. we could leave it here for an hour and it might still be good, but that doesn't actually prove anything as such. This is why in a bit and fires are such a pain in the ass, you can waste a lot of time. You can go down a lot of, you know, chasing a lot of red herrings down the rabbit hole and well, yeah, so, but it's not failing so far.

So I don't know you name the odds of the high voltage power supply section being at fault. I it's not I suspect it's on either vertical all the horizontal sections and that suspicion is backed up by. remember our +5 volt rail is the one that actually went down here and the output of this bridge rectifier was really loaded down. and by the way, it was that past transistor that was getting hot and this voltage regulator here you - I've actually checked the position on that on the component overlay and there was that one that was getting hot for that five volt rail.

So a five Volt rail over here. We've got assembly a 14 and it looks like a five volt rail doesn't go anywhere else. So I am suspecting a 14 over here I don't know what that is. We'll have to have a look.

Well, there you go. That doesn't help. Here's our power supply up here. This is the interconnecting board, the A14 interconnect.
We just start physically removed and that +5 Ox comes out of the power supply and goes off to both the horizontal sweep assembly and also to the vertical preamp assembly. so it could be either one of those horizontal or vertical. Well, thanks for that. And if we have a look at this rather complex looking interconnection diagram, our low voltage power supply here.

our +5 volt output here as we saw it goes off to the horizontal assembly down here and it also goes off to the vertical assembly in here. But then the +5 volts from the vertical assembly also goes over here as well. There's I You know the horizontal is pretty boring. there's not much doing in the horizontal, so I'm more just for it.

Sheer odds point of view. I think there's more likely to be stuff happening in the vertical channel. so I'm more suspecting the the vertical wire side earthing the vertical board then the horizontal board. But I mean you know it's just guessing.

Really? Okay, so what I'm going to do now is just have a quick check of the 5 volt ray or output current and we don't have to get in and break the circuit with our multimeter to measure the current at all because we've got ourselves a current limiting resistor here. this 1 Ohm resistor our 30. here. we can just measure the voltage across that and hopefully the voltage across it when it's not failed.

and then wait until it fails and then see if the voltage increases ie. the current increases. So let's give that a bell. There we go.

That's our 1 Ohm Current shunt resistor. I'm using These are parrot clips in there I Love through-hole parts like this. troubleshooting through-hole parts because you can get in there with your little easy hooks or your parrot clips or whatever or your even your alligator clips and we clip on to the components down at the solder on. You don't have to do anything, it's really easy so it will pair it on.

Yeah, we're working and we're getting 0.25 volts there. So we're looking at, you know, 250 milliamps on the 5 volt row. I'll just sit here, wait for it to fail. Hopefully it was failing before within a few minutes, so hopefully fingers crossed.

Oh, there we go. There we go. 4 volts. It's dropping our currents actually going down.

Yes, I've got it hooked up backwards. I Didn't know which way it went, so it's yeah. But no, our current hasn't increased. but look now, current hasn't increased.

but the voltage? That's 2 volts per division. So our AC output our rectified output tap has certainly dropped. Look at that. There we go.

I've powered it back up I've put the probes around the right way. So 250 milliamps and there's our normal. There's our normal ripple after our full wave rectifier. so 2, 4, 6.

Look, look slightly up. you see it drop. Did that drop? Oh, is that just my imagination? Anyway, 2 4, 6. Oh, did we get a glitch there? 2, 4, 6 and then oh wait, no, that's that's one sick puppy look at that.
But our current. You'll notice our current did not increase. so it's not like it's being overloaded. Bingo.

And just as a matter of course, I'm going to check the connections on the transformer input. There, they look. they look pretty darn good. No corrosion or anything on those.

So based on Kirchhoff's current law, what could be can be happening here. Where can If it is excess current, where can it be going? So say, for example, there's excess current on the output of this bridge rectifier and it is actually dragging this rail down and this diode bridge and this tap here can't can't supply the power required? Where is it going? Well, it's not going through here. It's not going out of here because here's our current sense resistor. It can.

There's only two places that can be going. One is somehow through the base of this transistor into now I Think Believe it's an LM 723 voltage regulator here, or it's going around here once again into a current limit pin. It doesn't seem likely at all. We've measured the voltage across here.

there is no excess current flowing out there, so I can only flow it there or there. Um, so it can't go anywhere else. So what's happening here? Well, as I said, if that capacity, if that was a bad capacitor, this 5300 micro farad cap, if that was, you know bad as well. It's you know, 35 years or 30 years old or whatever it is, 35 Is it? Um, yeah.

You'd certainly suspect that, but you'd see a lot a huge amount of excess ripple. That's what I would have expected. So I am starting to suspect either this transformer tap, which is highly unlikely. the interconnects in here, which is a plausible just like we had on the primary side.

We thought maybe there's a, you know, some sort of interconnect issue, or the Diode bridge and the capacitor. When we can prove I'm just whacking a 22 I think it's a 2200 microfarad 60 odd volt across the rail there. and well, let's have a look at our ripple as well and watch it. Okay, everything's working hunky-dory at the moment, but I suspect this puppy is going to fail and yet the scope scope still works so everything's fine.

I Think well stow. Oh he did. Did that just drop? Was that my it? No. Look, it's jumping around.

it's jumping around. Remember this is the voltage across that full wave rectified capacitor there. So I think if we wait I reckon it's going to drop and do exactly the same thing as before. I Yep, there we go.

it's dropped BAM voltage across there. four point four volts our voltage over our our five volt rail, the output of the voltage regulator. Four Point one. Bingo.

Even with the extra cap on there, so it ain't the cap. now you wouldn't know. It's really handy about having these transistors on the back and the connecters going straight on the pins. Because these are identical series pass transistors, we can swap them.
This is this one. Here is the one for our 5 volt channel that we're looking at here, but we can just swap it with this one here. so that's what I've done. What the--? the Y's are just long enough on an angle to get over there and plug in so we can see if the fault stays with the transistors swapped over.

We know there's not a problem with the training in some weird way, shape or form. Ok, it's still working and oops, sorry forgot to turn that back on. it's just discharging that cap and ripple I am just is jumping around here I reckon she'll fight. Yep, there we go.

Failed again. not the transistor. Not that I expected it to, but hey, because we can swap it. very quick.

easy test to do. Ok now what I've got is I'm just measuring the transformer output tap. There we can in can see that 9 volts Ac there and let's wait until see if we get a fire. I'll switch this back sorry I I move that a little bit there.

we go. Right there we go. Bingo, we're still getting it. Look, it's gone back up.

So that meant we're still getting the AC out of that transformer. No problems whatsoever. And because this looks like there's less load on it. look.

So what's left? Diode Bridge That Diode Bridge down there is our coal port. Because I was measuring on pin 7 and 80, Pin 1 starts over. Here goes straight another Diode Bridge. So I'm suspecting that puppy.

but I do stand corrected. It could potentially still be like the solder joint on those pins or maybe the connection inside there. but I can't really see any problem in there. It looks really good.

It could be you know it could be a dry joint on the bottom of this connector or the diode bridge itself. It may not be. The Dyer bridge could certainly be an old fashioned dry joint now. I Was about to say this is actually really quite easy to get out because the the war into the past.

Transistors on the back. just pull those off. Couple of these: disconnect the mains here. disconnect the secondary take off the plate there.

There's a couple of wires in there for our mains input. There's our main cell voltage selection switches for those fanboys, but there is two screws going to there that there that there's a bottom mount that's the mains power switch right there. Which is no surprise because here's the mains input. and there's a shaft which comes all the way on the bottom of the board and connects to there.

So oh, and I've got a disconnect. Carefully disconnect this connector here through to the bottom board. I've done that and I think it? sort of yeah. I don't know how that attaches under there cuz there's the whole high voltage supply on the back of that.

So jeez, I don't know. Well I figured it out. I Sort of move this slight. I've disconnected this main connector down here I can move it just like how like a half a centimetre towards the front panel here and then once I've got it on the front panel.
Tada, there's the line switch and the line switch. She's actually square, but it's protruding enough that it now lets me unscrew it. Tada. Look at that.

so I can unscrew the shaft from the main switch on the back. This is all very, very clever. and by the way, yes, I did eventually figure out that this is actually explained in the manual dole. So bingo this now with perhaps some difficulty, Hmm.

should actually come out somehow. Yeah, well. looky what we have here. Look at those pins.

Can I wiggle those in the bottom? Not a huge amount. Look at those dry joints Joys a dead dingos donger. But the funny thing is that's not the one that I'm suspecting. Okay, this is actually Cr3 I think it is.

which is the flood gun the high-voltage a flood gun tap which I wasn't looking at. this is the one that I'm interested in. that's the that's that tap for the Five Volt rail, but that looks that looks okay. So yeah, I don't know.

Anyway, so I'm not sure if I caused that problem by wiggling the connector out I don't know, but geez. I'm certainly going to fix it up. No joy. This here is the Diode.

No, sorry. This one is the Diode bridge we're interested in. So yeah, I'm going to replace that Diode bridge as a matter of course. that's for the Five Volt rail and also these ones on the other end too.

They might show up really well on the camera here, but to the naked eye they look like good joints I Had to look at those under the mantas microscope. The others look good. These ones also these two here. I'm not sure if this will show up on camera.

it's hard to see on the camcorder LCD here, but these ones will. These ones also have that cracks in them, but the one we're interested in this one here looks to be good. but I'm going to re solder this whole damn connector just as matter of course. and I decided that suspect Diode bridge And it's interesting to note no solder has flowed through to the top side of the component there like they have for the other components.

Look, all the other components solder has fed through. No problems at all. but on that Diode bridge, it suspiciously hasn't. I think I'm going to go through and resolder all the Do bridges.

It might not be anything wrong with the Diode bridge, but I will replace it with a new one or a new old stock as a matter of course. And that Diode bridge wasn't alone. IVA It looks like practically all of them are gonna have that same issue. None of the solder has flown through and granted, that should it be a problem.

but you're relying on the through-hole plating of the PCB itself and you'll notice that you know most of them have all the traces on the top half. If I flip it over, you'll see that very, very little is actually on the bottom there. So you've got to rely on all that top half connection right through thee. V is there that's asking for it, especially after 35 years, so that might not be a dodgy Diode bridge at all.
By the way, are the pad fell off in the repair there I was using a reasonable temperature but it just came off. so you know, 35 year old PCB man. but all of the most of the connections look all for that. Do bridge three for that one, three for that.

one, 3 for the 5 volt one under interest too. and all of the connections for that that we saw some really dodgy dry joints on I mean like completely cracked, right dry as a dead dingos donger. Every single one of those connects to the positive side. So if we had no solder flow through on these dire bridges, you could all assume that we had no solder flow through on those I didn't actually physically remove it and check it, but I sucked them all out.

It wouldn't sort of budge. there was some. you know it's quite hard to get these sort of things out sometimes depending on the hole size, but I resold them as a matter of course and all of the dire bridges. So yes, I did replace the one diode bridge on the top side.

there. There it is. so I replace that puppy there. but I probably didn't have to I suspect those now looking at those joints I don't think there was much wrong with those diet and that diet bridge at all.

I suspect it's just 35 year old solder joint problems and this problem has been probably been sitting in there waiting to happen for 35 years. Not adequate solder flow through like they got on these parts here. Look all the other parts, no problems at all, but maybe these higher thermal mass ones or maybe they were sold as separate or I don't know what the deal is. they had no flow through whatsoever and maybe the connector too.

So anyway, resold at all. Let's whack it back in. Okay and let's power it on and see what we get. I've only hooked up the 15 volt rail, but up helps if I plug it in plugged in.

We're getting four or five volts and we're getting our 9.8 Everything's hunky-dory Now all we've got to do is wait. but I suspect we've fixed it and I'll tell you what it seems to be the Diode bridge actually. I've had this thing jumping around I've just got it tested here. I'm supposed to be drawing like a half amp load from this puppy and and it's it was like 5 volts before and it's not.

It's just dropped, it's just dropped and it was actually jump back on. probably Murphy means I'm probably not going to be able to get it to jump back. Come on damn you. come on.

anyway. I reckon there's something thermally wrong with the with the you know the diodes inside this thing and that's probably our first. I Don't think I've ever like I've seen diode bridges blow but not ones that sort of, you know, intermittent thermally fail like that. So yeah, I'll see if I can nab it though.
There we go. I got it. This is what it's normally like. okay and hopefully we'll just see it suddenly jump.

Bingo Hey, just saw it gotcha There you go. It just jumped down and if we let it cool down, it actually recovers and it's repeat. All The Bloody Diode Bridge. Unbelievable.

So there you have it, the Eevblog curse has been lifted where I either when I get repair are stuff like this? It's either so incredibly simple to fix or it's BR beyond economical repair and you know, too complicated and expensive to fix. But this one? fantastic. I Hope you enjoyed a look at how I traced down to the Bloody Diode Bridge. Do you believe it? and potentially some solder joint issues as well.

Unbelievable. I Don't think I've ever seen a Diode bridge fail intermittently like that. Usually these, you know. Todd Bridges yeah, they fail, but they fail.

usually fail open like that and well, these ones, this was failing. not so much like open. If it failed open, then it would have been fairly easy to find that we weren't getting any voltage out and stuff like that. But because this thing had a quite unusual power supply arrangement in that all the voltage Rail references were actually tied to the 115 volt reference, then if the 5 volt one went down and there's all the other surgery it by some mechanism I Haven't gone in and you know, investigated the whole thing.

Maybe through another board or something like that can actually drag the other, the 15 volt rail down and then the 15 volt rail drags down all the other, rails as well. and you would have actually noticed that all of them are dropped by exactly the same same percentage as well. So that sort of, you know, clued in that they were all tied into the single 15 volt rail. But that was a fascinating troubleshooting look.

And like a power supply fault, right? Really, really simple. but because it failed in a very subtle and intermittent way, you saw how I actually got a little bit lucky here in terms of that. It did actually play ball in the and actually failed pretty much on cue and I could power it up. Wait a minute, it had fail, but it didn't do that the first time I played with it in my first video, it was.

you know, sitting there for four or five hours and wasn't doing a thing. So if it doesn't fail and well, we came up with it. you know, a couple of theories. The primary side seemed like a reasonable theory to check and I it was lucky that I went in and double-check that of course to make sure that the Abbott voltage taps had actually dropped as well as the five volt one.

I saw because if I did that, I might have gone off and you know I tried to look for some short end. By the way, if I followed the troubleshooting procedure in this thing, I might have to take a capture of it and show you it basically implies I think I read it out there I did show up before it says that the horizont if they all drop by 20% or whatever exactly what we saw here right all the rails drop, then you know they said either horizontal the vertical. You know it's likely to be in a fault. What that's off? You're strictly following the troubleshooting guide.
You may have gone down that rabbit hole thinking, ah, there's some sort of overload on the horizontal or the vertical boards and it's lucky that I Actually, well, it's not lucky I deliberately went in there and went before I Do that. I'll go in and check that. check the current. It's worth checking the current, double-checking checking things before you go down that rabbit hole chasing all those red herrings where you think it might be.

You know you might have fixed ten of these before and go. Ah yeah, it's been the vertical board or whatever. actually had a few people were email me since the first video on they said oh yeah, I've seen this, it's you know, the vertical border, it's this or it's that and stuff like that, nobody. Nobody picked a diode bridge and potentially some dodgy, dry solar small joints.

dry as a dead dingos. Dumber. Those things were amazing And typically you'd start out with troubleshooting something like this with a visual inspection, but you can't visually inspect those joints that we saw in there until you take out the whole board. So we I only had the measurement.

you know, just take some measurements to sort of see where we led. So I hope you like that troubleshooting I Could have made this video shorter. sorry, it's been like 45 minutes or something in the second one because it's been going for like an hour. I Just edited the footage and it was like 40 minutes.

Worth something? Yeah, for not for another five. Sorry, at least maybe ten. but we really got lucky with this puppy that it was such an obscure fault that you know you're not very likely to see something like this year. Intermittent faults or you know, happen all the time.

but usually something you know like that dry cracked joint it'd be. you know, ever a physical flex thing you might be able to, you know, flex the board just - I was poking around if the poker it didn't actually come and go then which indicates this probably wasn't the problem and end up being an obscure thermal issue that didn't just oh you know, fail open. it failed. sort of high impedance which was a different thing which made it look like and it you know it could have led you down the garden path.

you could I Could have easily wasted a lot of hours on this scope before eventually finding something like this. and that's the problem with bloody intermittent fires anyway. I Hope you enjoyed that and there's probably people who are saying on jeez. Dave that was.

That was pretty easy. It was just a bloody power supply. Why didn't you find that in five minutes? Well, I Basically, it did not take as long as what you see here. I was waffling on.
and you know, going through what was talking through, what was in my head and stuff like that, it might have been like an hour's worth of troubleshooting video. but in reality if I didn't have the camera on and I was just working on this, it was probably 10 15 minutes worth of work. So it's you know, it's probably not. It took me longer I Think to get the board out and then repair it, clean it up and put it back in.

Then it did to actually find the fault in the end. so it was a pretty quick repair in the scheme of things. So what are some quick lessons from? This one will always measure your voltages. Thou shalt measure voltages.

Golden Rule of troubleshooting: Don't assume something's overloaded. Actually measure the thing. Double check. If we didn't double check, we may have gone down.

You know, around. don't necessarily believe any instructions you have. Yes, they can be handy, but they might also lead you down the garden path as well. Got to have your thinking cap on.

And with these intermittent faults, don't just go around with you know a theory in your head. I Yeah, it's the primary side contacts and start cleaning all the contacts and going. Ah yeah, I fixed it because Murphy or bloody will get you I guarantee it that it'll You know it'll look fixed, it'll work for a week or whatever and then the thing will come back. But we got recently lucky on this one that it decided to sort of play ball.

but it may not have. This one could have been really ugly. so we made a couple of assumptions in here again. came up with a couple of theories, but we tried to verify them and then hey, I was wrong.

You know it wasn't the primary side, hey, but it was worth a quick you know the thirty second look just to measure it and make sure. But I We found it pointed somewhere else and then that pointed to another thing and bingo we found it. Beauty Never assumed and also this is not a bad example of where having multiple multimeters comes in handy. And potentially, even though we didn't get that far having a multi-channel scope, a lot of people ask, well, what use is a 4-channel scope? Well, you can measure for power supplies at the same time and see what they're doing and capture transiency.

We had some weird, you know, Fireboat. We may have gone down into that detail and maybe even because these are ground reference maybe you might have needed. Oh yeah, we didn't get this far, even if it might have needed a nicer multi-channel isolator does scope what this one? two channels. hopefully do a repair and tear down on this one too soon.

Ah, two isolated channels so that we can get in there and improve different points at the same time. fully isolated from any reference between scopes. So yeah, it's handy to have more than one meter. I Keep saying it.
Good example: I Hope you'll enjoy that that was a bloody Ripper I Love a good adventure hunt like that. So I hope you did too. If you want to discuss it, jump on over to the eevblog for links down below. all that sort of stuff.

I've got the warranty void if not removed t-shirt I'll probably linking that down below if I Remember, you usually don't Anyway, leave YouTube comments blog comment: Oh, let's sort of Jess catch you next time you.

Avatar photo

By YTB

29 thoughts on “Eevblog #804 – hp1740a oscilloscope repair – part 2”
  1. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Light Science says:

    I am developing a little device that uses a microcontroller and can read 20, 30, 40 plus voltages at once using a fast bench dmm with a digital output.
    It has all the probes and quickly jumps down the list, bridging the connections from the probes to the dmm.
    It logs the output and moves on, in a circle. The more probes you add the lower the update rate but with a keithley or a DMM that is very fast, it's good enough for 20 power rails.

    Let me know if you want to know more

  2. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars john king says:

    Thanks Dude,
    My scope lives on thanks to you. I too had dead dingo donger solder joints on that header. I think it's because that box rectifier gets hotter than a kangaroo kooch in December and causes thermal related fatigue stresses in those joints. Just a guess. I replaced the 9-volt rectifier with a Vishay w04g but you could use a lower voltage version.

  3. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Ernest B. says:

    "One sick puppy" ๐Ÿ™ƒ

  4. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Tony Fleming says:

    Nice job! Thanks for your videos!

  5. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars gixerags750 says:

    Very enjoyable video.

  6. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars CoolMusicToMyEars says:

    I just use Frezer spray Dave, a lot of HP & Tektronix use a reference PSU for a lot of other supplies its quite common to do this on instrumentation, I've had a 20 digit oliveti Calculator, scope output then replaced bridge rec, Oliveti could not find but I did, 5V ttl logic supply, always scope it

  7. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Randy Havard says:

    I think Dave is flexing on us with his multimeter collection

  8. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars papa uchu says:

    Hello, good morning. Sir, I bought a Tektronix 2465 300 MHz oscilloscope. It turns out that when turning on it takes a while for the flash or the image to appear, it is an analog oscilloscope, could you help me to know if the fault is serious or if it is due to lack of maintenance,
    The equipment turns on but the screen is displayed after a long time, help me to know if it is something serious please

  9. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Barry Bogart says:

    I just bought one of these at a hamfest in Canada. I watched Dave's two videos before even turning it on, with some trepidation. Anyway it seems to work perfectly. But now I have Dave's guide in case it goes awry. I already have six DMMs.

  10. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars David Wilkie says:

    Anything with "scope" in the name is very important, but the Oscilloscope is at top. The up-to-date time-timing sync-duration Instrument detector of generic e-Pi-i Reciproction-recirculation QM-TIME Completeness In-form-ation cause-effect.

  11. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars War Planner says:

    Good job, Dave. But, before you and the other folks here go stark-assed crazy anointing the inside of you HP 1740s with Deoxit be very careful to consider drip and runoff patterns. The 1740 has a proprietary chip under a massive heat sink (as I recall) that is directly under the drip path of the function switch contacts. If the Deoxit or other switch cleaner leaks into the chip, it could short the leads and you're S.O.L.!

    This from personal experience at my converting a 1740 from a two-channel scope to a one-channel one.

  12. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars mikecoller says:

    Very entertaining and informative

  13. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars EBAY STARS says:

    "dry as a dead dingo's donga", BLIMEY !

  14. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars DGV Creative Channel says:

    Hello

  15. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Franco Maria Nardini says:

    great work Dave! I really liked your debugging methodology! congrats!

  16. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Paul Cohen says:

    The diode bridges are GI General Instruments.
    Almost sure 99.9%
    (Written before Dave final verdict)

  17. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Bryce Michel says:

    That failed diode is going straight in the pool room

  18. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Waltkat says:

    Thank you so much for this. This video will be helpful when I get around to repairing my two dead HP 1740A scopes.

  19. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Mario Mionskowski says:

    Sometimes it is realy comfortable if you can it read.

  20. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Big Cheese says:

    No, those round diode rectifiers are dodgy af!
    I traced an intermittent fault in a really expensive Siemens flow meter failing exactly as that one.

  21. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Robert plays says:

    as an interesting footnote to the odd behavour of the bridge rectifire could have been tracked down very easerly by applying the thermal test using a freeze spray this was a common practice when i used to sevice solid state equipment allthough these days this verry useful diagnostic tool seems to be used less and less in the workshop envirement i wonder why?

    De Bob G7DME

  22. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    Then again, in thirty five years, anything can go wrong!

  23. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    I wonder how long this scope functioned properly, with those failed solder joints?

  24. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Anto Nio says:

    I own a HP 1740A and i was just looking around in net to see about info… just curious… untill i dropped in your channel… I was letterally captured by your nice explanation on the fault analysis!
    It was better than to watch a thriller or spy movie!
    To make all more interesting is the video quality, and the very good explanation that pointing on schematic.
    I'm not English mother language so it was a little hard somethimes to follow your fast speaking… but fortunately i get it all.
    Thank you for your passion, and for sharing your knowledge.
    and… "Bingo"…. I subscribed in your channel !

  25. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    "Dry as a dead Dingo's donger", Classic!

  26. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    "A wiggle and a jiggle." Dave might have a hit single on the charts!

  27. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    Fluke are the best meters…Good God!!!

  28. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Don Matejek says:

    Wire traces and components can be bad in electronics…I knew this from many years in my youth…Great lesson Dave!!!

  29. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars islandhopperstuart says:

    Superb video Dave. I learn so much from these videos!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *